How to Sell
Want to Consign with Us? Here’s How it Works:
We sell your clothes on consignment, which means you get paid after your items sell. You’ll earn 30%–60% of the sale price, depending on the item's price.
Step 1: Schedule an Appointment
To manage demand, our consignment calendar opens weekly on the following schedule:
- Sunday at 11am for the upcoming weekday appointments
- Friday at 11am for the upcoming weekend appointments
Spots book up quickly so we recommend going on to the Square booking page right when appointments are released at 11am!
Step 2: Bring In Your Items
At your appointment, we’ll look through what you bring and let you know what we can take and how we'll price it. Items we accept will stay in-store for 2.5–3 months. After that, you can choose to pick up anything that didn’t sell, or donate it.
What to Bring
We’re currently looking for fall/winter items that are clean and in great shape (no stains, rips, or pet hair). We love cool, vintage, and unique styles!
Favorite Brands: Abercrombie, Anthropologie, ASOS, Babaton, Doc Martens, Free People, Frye, Levi’s, Lululemon, Reformation, Ralph Lauren, Tripp NYC, Urban Outfitters, Wilfred, Zara, Coach and more, as well as vintage brands.
Brands We Tend to Pass on: SHEIN, Forever 21, Joy Lab, A New Day, Wild Fable, Universal Thread, Old Navy, Loft, Ann Taylor, and any Designer Brands
For more info, check out our quarterly buying guide below!
WINTER 2026 BUYING GUIDE
How You Get Paid
Most items sell for $5–$69, with higher prices for rare or luxury pieces. You’ll earn 30%–60% of the final sale price. Track your sales in our consignor portal. You can collect payouts via direct deposit by filling out this form. We process deposits every Tuesday via PayPal.
Effective 3/1/2026 we will be switching to the below consignment split:
30% for items under $10
40% for items $10-19.99
50% for items $20-$49.99
60% for items $50+
A Few Things to Keep in Mind
Trendy, casual, and vintage items sell best. Think overalls, cowboy boots, funny tees, etc.
Formal and business clothes don’t do as well with our customers — consider other resale options for those.
We do not specialize in designer items or collectable sneaker brands.
If we can’t take something, it’s not personal! We have limited space and have to choose what we know will sell.
We price to sell — this means you may earn less than you would online, but you skip the hassle of photographing, listing, and shipping.
Have questions? We're happy to help!
Email us at hello@thriftpony.com